Skip to main content

AGREE TO DISAGREE






The other day NAUTICAL LOG received a video from The Institute of Cetacean Research which showed a RHIB from the MS Bob Barker. The RHIB came up the starboard side of the MS Yushin Maru #2 and deployed a rope in an attempt to foul the propeller of the whale catcher.

Things did not go too well for the nautical thugs confrontation with the harpoon hooligans!!

When the RHIB deployed the rope it did so over its own port quarter then powering ahead of the MS Yushin Maru #2 on its starboard side the RHIB closely crossed the bow of the catcher to its port side. Of course in doing so the RHIB crossed its own line, appeared to foul it and slowed down or stopped. Having reviewed the video at least a dozen times it is however not entirely clear what was fouled. The RHIB then drifted at right angles to the MS Yushin Maru #2 was girthed and nearly flipped over, with the line apparently still attached on the RHIB's port quarter. It should of course been released or cut free immediately there was a problem. Now NAUTICAL LOG has completed a RHIB handling course conducted by a Californian Marine Rescue Group (copy of that course certificate is shown) and believe me this is not the way to handle a RHIB under these conditions.

Being fair and balanced NAUTICAL LOG e-mailed the SSCS to find out just what training these people had because they are heading for a serious tragedy. We await a reply from the MS Bob Barker but in the meantime there was a Press Release by SSCS. According to their version of events all is as we described with the explanation that their RHIB stopped due to:

"The inflatable became disabled after the confrontation with the Japanese whaling vessel, solely due to damage to the pontoon from prolonged pounding against heavy seas".

Well maybe but this does not say much for the quality of construction of the RHIB or its maintenance. RHIBS are designed and tested most rigorously with just this sort of heavy weather in mind. NAUTICAL LOG cannot believe that ZODIAC, the RHIB's manufacturer, is too pleased to hear this SSCS explanation from 'Wats-his-name' and it would be most interesting to have the ZODIAC opinion on the incident.

NAUTICAL LOG does not believe the SSCS explanation is very plausible and while it is possible we tend to believe that poor RHIB handling and tactics is the more likely true explanation. 'Wats-his-name' is very well known for blaming other people for things that happen and never himself the master seaman. So we must agree to disagree in this case and hope for a comment from ZODIAC, after all there are many manufacturers of RHIBs and we have it would seem better choices when it comes to selecting heavy weather rescue vessels.

Good Watch.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

PAINT LOCKER FIRES

The photographs above are revealing in several ways, lets have a look. Clearly the Japanese Maritime Self Defence Force (JMSDF) vessel JS "Kurama" impacted the Korean container ship MS "Carina Star" just aft of the turn of the fo'cs'le on the Starboard side. Please note that's the Starboard side, thus it appears JS "Kurama" would have shown "Carina Star" the red port sidelight and "Carina Star" would have shown JS "Kurama" the green starboard sidelight. This impact point would tend to suggest that JS "Kurama" was the 'stand-on' vessel and the MS "Carina Star" is the 'giving-way' vessel. Until there is a complete plot of the tracks made good of both these vessels and the position in the Kanmon Strait of the point of collision no determination can actually be made. As a result of this impact there was severe bow damage to JS "Kurama" and in addition a massive f...
Post a Comment
Read more

HOW TO WEAR A LIFEJACKET

A popular U.S.-based cruise ship style A popular European ferry style Several times during the year NAUTICAL LOG has had visitors searching for lifejacket instructions. With two just over Christmas we decided to publish something for everybody to see and read. Choose a Coast Guard approved life-jacket and make sure it is undamaged. Make sure life-jackets are readily accessible, never locked away. Check the fit, there are adult, child and infant sizes, the correct one MUST be used. Choose bright colour life-jackets so as to be seen easily by Search and Rescue (SAR). Put your life-jacket ON BEFORE you leave the berth. Make sure you have a light and whistle attached AND they BOTH WORK. Good Watch
Post a Comment
Read more

CYCLONES AND SENTINELS

USCG Sentinel-class which are based on the Netherlands Damen Stan-class USCGC opened hull view USCG Sentinel-class interior layout USN Cyclone-class In the NAUTICAL LOG Press Release folder comes news of Bollinger Shipyards in Lockport, LA. The United States Coast Guard has awarded a $166.1 million option to start production of four ' Sentinel-class' Fast Response Cutters (FRCs). This latest award brings a total of eight FRCs under production at Bollinger with a value of $410.7 million. The current FRC contract contains options for up to 34 cutters and is worth $1.5 billion if they are all exercised. Recently the United States Navy limited operation of its 'Cyclone-class' coastal patrol boats stationed in Bahrain and Norfolk, VA. Any vessel operation would depend on sea state and speed restrictions. This was due to structural damage as the vessels reach the 15 year mark which is considered close to the operational limit. This is apparently not a design fault but ...
Post a Comment
Read more